Senator Saleem Mandviwalla, who chairs the Senate Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue, has put a number on a cost most card users never see: between $300 million and $400 million leaves Pakistan each year because purchases made in rupees, inside the country, are handled by international card networks. The figure is his own estimate, and he did not explain how it was worked out.
He raised it on Thursday, 19 November, when a delegation from the committee met members of the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry. His point was that parliamentary oversight exists to find leaks of this kind, keep foreign exchange in the country and protect the public, and he offered the card-routing outflow as one of the committee’s examples.
A second example touches account holders directly. Banks add SMS alert fees to accounts without the customer having agreed to them, and the committee wants that compulsory element removed. If it succeeds, an alert fee would apply only to people who opted in.
The senator also credited the committee with stopping roughly Rs. 120 billion of unnecessary government spending each year under the Pakistan Remittance Initiative. The chamber’s press release about the visit carries that claim, and it comes with no breakdown either.
The rest of his message was for businessmen. Instead of showing up only when the budget is near, he said, the chamber should stay in touch with parliamentary committees all year and send researched proposals two to three months before budget preparation begins. Proposals that are genuine, he promised, will be put in front of the government.



