Friday, 20 November 2026

UK tribunal rules government can’t keep Apple’s encryption order secret

The Home Office failed to convince a UK tribunal that confirming its order to Apple would harm security, so most of the case can be heard in public.

Key points

  • The UK tribunal found the Home Office had not shown that confirming Apple's order would harm national security.
  • Most of the case can now be heard in public; some parts stay private or closed.
  • The full hearing is now expected in the first half of 2027, not December 2026.

The UK government has lost its argument that it must stay silent on whether it served Apple with an order over users’ encrypted data. Ministers said confirming it would harm national security, and the surveillance tribunal did not accept that.

The decision means Apple and the privacy groups challenging the order can now argue most of their case in open court. Apple can also say publicly that it received the order, something it had been restricted from doing while the secrecy dispute ran.

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal issued its judgment on 19 November 2026. The order in question is a technical capability notice, a power the Home Secretary has through the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 (section 253) to make a company keep the ability to hand over users’ data in readable form. Apple’s claim runs alongside a separate complaint from Privacy International, Liberty, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner.

Ministers stick to a standing line of never saying either way whether a notice exists. The three judges found it had not applied that policy consistently: The Times and the Financial Times both reported that officials had confirmed the notice, and the tribunal concluded those briefings were authorised by ministers or senior officials. The Home Office filed no evidence to the contrary. In the tribunal’s words, anyone with even a passing interest in the subject already knows Apple was served, and the idea that official confirmation would help a hostile actor is fanciful.

The judges also noted that counsel to the tribunal pointed out the government’s own documents on the matter are marked official sensitive, not secret or top secret, which sat badly with the claim that disclosure would damage national security.

This follows an earlier round of the same fight. In early 2025 Apple brought its first claim, and the government said even the existence of the case must stay secret. In a ruling dated 7 April 2025 the tribunal refused that too, which is how the public learnt that Apple was suing the Home Secretary over this power.

The ruling does not open everything. The contents of the notice stay undecided: the tribunal said some detail may need to remain secret, and that the line is best drawn after the sides exchange evidence. Parts of the hearing are still likely to run in private or closed sessions, especially the question of whether the order is a proportionate interference with human rights.

The hearing itself has moved. The NGOs’ claim had been listed for December 2026, but the judgment says all sides agree that date is impractical and expect to aim for the first half of 2027.

Maroof Saeed

Author/Writer at Tech Prolonged You will mostly see him posting about Android stuff. Reach him on social networks below. @Twitter Facebook