Thursday, 19 November 2026

DRAM collusion case against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron survives dismissal

A California federal judge says buyers' claim that the three DRAM giants coordinated supply cuts is plausible enough for trial, so the case moves forward.

Key points

  • A US judge denied the chipmakers' motion to dismiss the DRAM supply-conspiracy class action.
  • Samsung, SK hynix and Micron must answer by 7 December; a hearing is set for 12 January 2027.
  • The allegations are unproven; the ruling only lets the case continue.

The three companies that make most of the world’s computer memory will have to defend themselves in court. A federal judge in California has ruled that buyers can keep pursuing claims that Samsung, SK hynix and Micron coordinated to keep ordinary DRAM, the kind in DDR5 modules, scarce while their factories chased AI memory. Nothing has been proven.

The decision came on 14 November from Judge Noël Wise, who denied the companies’ request to end the case early. The test at this stage is only whether the buyers’ story is believable if taken as true. The three firms must file their answers by 7 December, and the first case-management hearing is now set for 12 January 2027.

Behind it is a June complaint from 17 buyers (individuals and small companies) living in five states. Their argument: the three suppliers held more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025, trimmed output from late 2022 and then moved factory capacity to high-bandwidth memory, which needs three to four times the silicon per gigabyte of DDR5. Ordinary DRAM then became 171.8% pricier in a year, according to the complaint, and none of the three has announced a real expansion.

The companies called it a rerun of a 2016 to 2018 case that the Ninth Circuit threw out in 2022. In her order the judge said it is different. What tipped it, in her view: multi-year supply deals for AI memory, reported refusals to sign long-term deals for ordinary DRAM, Micron’s 3 December 2025 decision to shut its Crucial consumer brand, delayed or halted fabs, and near-identical customer questions that all three allegedly introduced in January 2026. Moves like these are hard to reverse, she wrote, and look unlikely without a prior understanding. She also noted that the vetting began long after AI demand took off, which weakens the companies’ claim that demand alone explains it.

Not everything counted. Investor remarks about “supply discipline”, executives sharing conference halls, and the fact that only three firms dominate the market all earned no weight from the court. When the defendants quoted the idea that rivals in concentrated markets “watch each other like hawks”, she answered that these claims describe “hawks flying in formation”.

Memory is already squeezing gadget budgets: DJI blamed memory chips for the price changes it set for 18 November. This ruling changes none of that, since a trial is far off and the companies’ position is that each acted in its own interest.

TPRO Team

The Tech Prolonged newsroom desk. Stories under this byline cover AI, the web and general tech, and are reviewed by our editors before publishing.